By Janet Paleo
•
April 14, 2026
Who is the expert? Is it the person with the degree, the clipboard, and the carefully chosen language—or the person who has lived through the storm and found their way back? For generations, we have been taught to look outward for answers, to trust authority over experience, while the people most affected are often spoken about instead of spoken with. Yet expertise does not come only from textbooks or training; it comes from resilience, from trial and error, from learning what it takes to survive and still hope. This story begins with a simple but radical idea: that wisdom is not only taught—it is lived. I have witnessed this repeatedly over the last month or two. People are being told to “listen” to the experts—experts who do not allow the person any meaningful input at all. They define the goals, set the limits, and decide what is “realistic,” often without ever asking the person what matters to them. They tell people what to believe and who they are allowed to become. And I will tell you this: no one knows you like you know you. People will tell us that we cannot trust our own minds. I was once told I had a “broken brain”—language that reduces a human being to a defect. That belief shaped how others treated me, and for a time, how I treated myself. I believe we can trust our minds. Often, the problem is not that our thoughts or behaviors are meaningless, but that the people engaging with us do not know how to understand them. They do not see that whatever we are doing—however confusing or frightening it may appear—is a way to survive, a way to make sense of a world that often does not make sense. When others believe they have our answers, expertise turns into manipulation and control. And under pressure, many of us give in—not because it is right, but because it feels like the easiest path. The consequences, however, are enormous. You wind up in hospitals, wondering if you will ever get out. You lose your voice. People talk at you, not to you. The more this happens, the more you may retreat inward. And then the system responds, “See? We were right.” When someone tells you that you are not thinking clearly, they may be right—from their point of view. But there is always a reason we do what we do, say what we say, or appear to lose control. All behavior has a purpose. Others may not see the purpose of lying in a fetal position or screaming at the top of your lungs. Systems often prioritize comfort over understanding, compliance over curiosity. They want the behavior to stop so they can be comfortable—not necessarily so the person can heal. When I was attacked and left for dead, I got myself home. I told no one what had happened. My mother believed it was always the girl’s fault if she was attacked, so silence felt safer. No one could figure out what was “wrong” with me. I would not—could not—leave my bed. A doctor decided I must have mononucleosis, even though the tests did not support that conclusion. It took six weeks before I could finally get out of bed. They could not see—or speak—the language of trauma. What looked like illness was trauma. And what they tried to erase were the very responses that had kept me alive. Often, people just want symptoms to disappear because symptoms make others uncomfortable. Yet those same symptoms are what allow us to survive what we have endured. Taking them away without understanding where they came from—and without replacing them with safer, healthier coping strategies—can leave us vulnerable, frightened, and misunderstood. It can even lead someone to question whether they want to remain on this earth at all. Expertise without relationship becomes power over, not power with. When people are excluded from decisions about their own lives, harm is often labeled as help. The question we must ask is not how quickly someone can be fixed, but how deeply they can be understood. Never give your power completely to another person. Always retain your voice in what happens to you. If you do not fully trust your mind, seek opinions—but understand that the choice is ultimately yours. Because even if you follow someone else’s advice and it does not go well, you are the one who will live with the consequences. That means you deserve the authority to choose. And if your choice does not turn out as you hoped, you have learned something valuable. You now know what not to do next time. These lessons matter. They are how we grow. Each one strengthens our voice—and strengthens us. So who is the expert? The expert is not the loudest voice in the room, the title on the door, or the person holding the chart. The expert is the one living the life. The one who knows what hurts, what helps, and what hope looks like from the inside. When we honor lived experience, we do not reject professional knowledge—we complete it. Healing begins the moment people are no longer spoken over, but listened to. And that is where real change begins—when we finally listen.